Romantic Anniversary Gifts for Her

Unique Gift Ideas for your Valentine

Don’t just settle for roses or cheap chocolates. We’ve curated the best list of Valentine’s Day Gifts for Her. These are truly thoughtful and one-of-a-kind gifts that will show her how much you care. 

We’re proud to showcase many handmade items from various talented artists, and partner with Uncommon Goods to bring you products are made by independent makers from around the world, saving you from generic and unmemorable gifts.

This post contains affiliate links, for which we may earn a small commission. We only ever promote companies and products that we personally trust & believe in.
Goldilocks Effect
Valentine's Day Gifts for Her - Goldilocks Effect Gift Guides

Thoughtful Valentine's Day Gifts for Her

Our selection of unique, romantic & personalized Valentine’s Day gifts is designed to help you find the perfect present without breaking the bank. Goldilocks Effect is here to help you find that “just right” Valentine’s Day gift.

Open-Minded Couple Mugs

A playful interpretation of staying “open minded,” the design fills with nearly 3 cups of coffee or tea.

The Edison Love Lamp

This joyful LED lamp will brighten spaces with love. Edison style bulb &  red cedar base.
Light up a loved one’s life—across town or across the country—with two or more of these in-sync lamps. When you turn one on with a simple touch of your hand, its mate emits the same ambient glow, no matter where it is and who is on the other end

Long Distance Love Lamps

How Do I Love Thee From A-Z

With 26 prompts laid out in a delightful typewriter font, reminisce about your most romantic moments and inside jokes & endearing quirks and charms. 

Poetic Love Personalized Art

The words from your favorite poem or quote are transformed into a 3-D work of art with you and your loved one’s initials and special date.

Love Soap with Box

Lotus-scented and packaged in a handmade box, this heart-shaped soap makes a lovely gift.

Heart U Ringholder

 The little things remind us that we’re loved: a hug, a note, a piece of jewelry. Let them know you care with this unique sculpture and ring holder.

Lovebox Spinning Heart Messenger

Modern meets magical! Send heartfelt messages to loved ones—anytime, anywhere in the world—with this modern take on the classic love note. 

When you send a new message through the easy-to-use app, the chunky heart on the beechwood box spins to alert the recipient. Then, the object of your affection opens the box to read the sentiment on the mirrored screen inside. They can return the virtual embrace by spinning the heart to send a shower of digital hearts to the sender’s screen. 

Intersection of Love

Commemorate the moment your paths first crossed with this personalized art with you and your sweetie’s names and the important dates.

Heart of Glass

Glass blowing duo Alyssa Getz and Tommy Cudmore make these dazzlingly colorful realistic heart sculptures by hand.

Rooted in Love Swing Sculpture

The artist hand-sculpts each copper piece, giving it a sweet swing that really moves.

Personalized Mug Set

Like young lovers carving their initials into a tree, this handmade pair of mugs recreates the ultimate romantic gesture.

Manhattan Fruitier Valentine's Gift Basket

Deliciously decadent Belgian Caramel Apple, Chocolates Ganache Hearts and Fresh Roses are sure to melt her heart  – a gourmet luxury that will delight the senses and the tastebuds.

Personalized Lunar Phase of Love

Images from the lunar calendar mark a special occasion in this personalized print.

Personalized Constellation of Love

Remember the moment just as it was with a personalized night sky featuring star charts from a specific date.

The Kissing Mugs

Shaped like faces kissing, these mugs are the perfect companions to coffee with your perfect companion.

Love + Magic Print

Adrienne Vita represents the magical connection between two partners in love in her imaginative print featuring two lovers.

Personalized Wood Cut City Map

Where the Heart Is

Call us romantics, but we think it’s possible to be in love with a city. Celebrate the locale that means the most to you with this detailed, laser-cut wooden and cork map.

In this extra special personalized version, you can not only mark your favorite spots using the included heart pins, but also display a meaningful address right in the middle of the map.

 Make it a memorable gift for lovers, newlyweds, travelers, or anyone in your life with a special connection to a certain city.

Personalized Champagne Vase

Made from a champagne bottle, this keepsake is a reminder to always celebrate with bouquets and bubbly. Add your names and special date for a romantic keepsake.

Etched Champagne Flutes

Toast a favorite couple or celebrate a special holiday with the timeless charm of these hand-engraved personalized champagne flutes. Makes a perfect Valentine’s Day or Anniversary present.

Lovers Tree Carved Initials Vase

Ceramicist Laurel Begley creates a fresh take on a romantic tradition of lovers carving their initials in trees.

Personalized Tree Trunk Glassware Set

Celebrate a couple’s love of wine, beer, or both with these hand-engraved sweetheart glasses.

Heart to Heart Necklace

This sterling silver heart cradling a smaller bronze heart necklace serves as a stylish reminder of a treasured relationship.

Lace Heart Necklace

These amorous accessories are each lovingly handcrafted from vintage lace dipped in precious metals.

Personalized All Heart Necklace

Celebrate love with this elegant necklace made just for you and your sweetheart. Customize rings with your names. 

Always In My Heart Necklace

Show a special someone that they’re always in your heart with this simply sweet birthstone necklace.

Horseshoe Heart Trivet

A horseshoe is both a good luck symbol, and a reminder of a simpler way of life. This rustic trivet is an upcycled horseshoe embraced by a swirling heart of hand-hammered steel.

Lucky Love Wind Chime

As the wind flows through these enchanting bells, we hope the chimes remind you: You are always loved. Handcrafted with a recycled steel “lucky” horseshoe and tiny bells

Evergreen Love Serving Platter

“Love, forever” is a frequent wish—for newlyweds, for anniversaries, for anyone celebrating love. This platter gives that wish resonance of something evergreen and always fresh—especially because it’s personalized.

Personalized Lovebirds Serving Bowl

A pair of doves watch a sunrise. The couple’s names run up a branch, and quote from Atticus Poetry forms the roots: “I want to be with someone, who dreams of doing everything in life, and nothing, on a rainy Sunday afternoon.”

Love Message Shortbread Cookies

A fun alternative to candy hearts, these rich, subtly flavored, not-too-sweet shortbread cookies say it with flavor.

With Love
Chocolate Cards

These fun folding cards conceal bars of delectable caramel-filled chocolate with space inside for you to draft your own personal love note.

Ceramic "Love"
Vase Set

Sculptural ceramic vases spell out what’s most important: LOVE. A beautiful to remind your family daily that you hold them in your heart. 

Heart to Heart
Timer Sculpture

Set this kinetic swinging heart in motion for forty minutes of focus; write a romantic letter, call someone special, or daydream about finding true love.

Dancing Mosaic Letters

The tiny, sparkly circles on these eye-catching letters spell out your initials. Cut from from recycled aluminum cans, they shimmer and dance. 

Personalized Tree Wood Carving

The next-best thing to carving your initials into a real tree trunk. This fully customizable piece will showcase your love forever. 

Da Vinci Code Mini Cryptex

This brainteaser is the perfect vessel for a small gift or love note. The default password is iloveu, which you are able to change if your choose.

Heart in Hand Sculpture & Jewelry Holder

This stoneware sculpture represents the willingness to give and receive love, and the need to protect it.

Couples Bucket List

100 Unique Date Night Idea Cards for couples — 3 bucket list categories that will help you to bring love and laughter into your relationship.

Love & Naughty
O-ing Tower

Play this love & naughty stacking tower board game and create a night filled with fun, romance and laughter!

Hanging Heart Vases

Sculptural vase meets exquisitely-colored suncatcher in this striking, hanging glass vessel. Handblown by Terry Weaver, the unique, heart-like glass form features a split, double opening to display fresh flowers or rooting plants, while the organic, contrasting color motif complements the plant forms within. 

The rims of the two openings meet, forming a space to accept a ribbon (included) or wire for hanging the piece in a window or doorway for all to admire.


Succulent Heart Wood Planter

Hand planted: these beautiful living succulent wall heart planters are handmade with love, fresh to order! 

Live Hoya Heart Plant
& Love Pot

Grow your love with this unique, long-lasting Hoya heart-shaped, low-maintenance plant that grows like a succulent.

Terrarium Candles

These irresistible hand-poured cactus and poppy candles are meticulously detailed and smell heavenly, scented with premium fragrance oils.

Personalized Map Candle

This hand-poured soy wax candle lets you celebrate your anniversary with candlelight and bubbly anytime. Customize with your special location. 

Map of Our Hearts Personalized Print

Route To Love

You may come from different places, but your love finally brought you two together. Cutting out half-hearts from vibrant vintage and modern maps, this print merges your worlds together in a charming heart motif.

Your names and an important date you share completes the personalized art piece, creating a perfect gift for newlyweds, long distance loves, and friends separated by roads and oceans. 

Hand-Carved Heart Serving Spoon

Share some sweet love and gratitude with this hand-carved spoon. Perfect gift to remind her of your love.

Box of Heart-Shaped Tea Bags

These heart-shaped tea bags are inspired by the joy of spending time relaxing & unwinding. 

Personalized Love Cutting Board

This custom-etched cherry wood cutting board features your family’s unique equation.  In circles or hearts, place up to four names that “add up to” either a last name or sweet message. Custom-etched cherry wood. 

Nesting Hearts Ceramic Bowls

Every pair in a love nest needs a pair of nesting heart bowls. These nesting bowls are beautifully handmade and painted in Mexico with traditional folk designs, are a pure red shade that vibrantly proclaims, “I love you!” 

For Him


Eco Friendly

Funny Friend

Book Lovers

For Baby

Toddler to Preschool

School Age

Romantic Valentine's Day Gifts for Her